Back to Healthcare Access

Health Insurance Denial: Appeal & Win Your Coverage

Treatment denied? Prior authorization rejected? You have powerful appeal rights. 83% success rate for properly appealed claims. Learn how to fight denials, navigate the appeal process, and win your coverage.

83%
Appeal Success Rate
$5K-$100K+
Average Coverage Value
60 Days
Internal Appeal Window
2025
California AI Ban Effective

Start Your Appeal - Get Personalized Guidance

Tell us about your denial and we'll provide specific appeal strategies

Health Insurance Denial Appeal

Get expert guidance on fighting your insurance denial

Our AI will analyze your description and guide you through the next steps

Understanding Health Insurance Denials

Know the types of denials and why they happen

Types of Coverage Denials

Medical Necessity Denials
Insurer claims treatment not medically necessary or appropriate
Experimental/Investigational
Treatment labeled as experimental or not proven effective
Prior Authorization Issues
Pre-approval required but denied or delayed indefinitely
Out-of-Network Denials
Provider not in network or balance billing disputes
Plan Exclusions
Treatment excluded from coverage in plan documents

Your Core Rights

Written Explanation
Detailed denial reason with specific plan provisions cited
Internal Appeal Rights
At least one level of appeal within insurance company
External Review
Independent review if internal appeal fails (binding on insurer)
Expedited Review
Fast-track appeals (72 hours) for urgent medical situations
Access to Records
Right to see all documents used in denial decision

Why Insurers Deny Claims (The Reality)

Stated Reasons:

  • •Protecting members from ineffective treatments
  • •Following evidence-based medicine guidelines
  • •Ensuring appropriate use of healthcare resources
  • •Adhering to plan terms and coverage limits

Financial Reality:

  • •Denied claims improve profitability and stock prices
  • •Most patients don't appeal (only 1 in 10 appeal)
  • •AI systems auto-deny based on cost, not medicine
  • •Bonus structures reward claim reviewers for denials

Key Insight: Studies show that 50-80% of insurance denials are overturned on appeal, revealing that many initial denials lack legitimate medical justification.

Common Denial Issues & How to Fight Back

Specific strategies for the most frequent insurance denial scenarios

Experimental/Investigational Treatment Denials
Insurance denies treatment as "experimental" or "not medically necessary"

Success Rate
72%
Average Value
$50,000-$300,000

Prior Authorization Delays & Denials
Treatment requires pre-approval that is denied or indefinitely delayed

Success Rate
83%
Average Value
$5,000-$100,000
California 2025 ban makes AI-only denials illegal

AI-Based Claim Rejections
Algorithm or automated system denies claim without individual review

Success Rate
89%
Average Value
$10,000-$75,000

Emergency Care Denials
ER visit or emergency treatment denied as "not emergency" or "inappropriate"

Success Rate
91%
Average Value
$2,000-$50,000

Out-of-Network Billing Disputes
Unexpected bills from out-of-network providers or surprise billing

Success Rate
78%
Average Value
$5,000-$100,000

Step Therapy / Fail First Requirements
Must try cheaper treatments first before coverage of prescribed treatment

Success Rate
69%
Average Value
$3,000-$50,000

The Appeal Process: Step-by-Step

Navigate internal and external appeals to win your coverage

1

Internal Appeal

First level - within insurance company

Timeline:
  • • 180 days to file after denial
  • • Insurer must decide in 30 days
  • • Urgent: 72 hours maximum
What to Submit:
  • • Written appeal letter
  • • Doctor's supporting letter
  • • Medical records/test results
  • • Clinical studies/evidence
  • • Request for peer review
Success Rate:
50-60%
2

External Review

Independent review - binding on insurer

Timeline:
  • • 4 months to file after internal denial
  • • Decision in 45-60 days
  • • Urgent: 4 business days
Process:
  • • Request through state agency
  • • Independent medical experts review
  • • No cost or minimal fee
  • • Decision is binding
  • • Insurer must comply
Success Rate:
75-90%
3

Legal Action

If external review fails or isn't available

Options:
  • • State insurance complaint
  • • Department of Labor (ERISA)
  • • Bad faith lawsuit (non-ERISA)
  • • Attorney representation
ERISA Limits:
  • • Can only recover denied benefits
  • • No punitive damages
  • • No jury trial
  • • Limited attorney fees
Non-ERISA:
  • • Bad faith damages available
  • • Punitive damages possible
  • • Jury trial right
  • • Attorney fees recoverable

Maximizing Your Appeal Success

Essential Documentation:

  • Doctor's letter: Detailed explanation of medical necessity with clinical justification
  • Medical records: Complete history, test results, prior treatments attempted
  • Clinical evidence: Peer-reviewed studies, treatment guidelines, expert opinions
  • Policy analysis: Cite specific plan language supporting coverage
  • Comparable cases: Examples of insurer approving same treatment for others

Strategic Tips:

  • Request peer-to-peer review: Have doctor speak directly with insurer's medical reviewer
  • Use expedited process: If medically urgent, demand 72-hour turnaround
  • Document everything: Keep copies, track dates, record phone calls (if legal in your state)
  • CC state regulators: Copy state insurance department on appeals to signal oversight
  • Consider appeal services: Patient advocate services have 80%+ success rates
NEW 2025

California's Groundbreaking AI Denial Ban

SB 1120 prohibits AI-only claim denials - a major victory for patient rights

What the Law Does

Prohibited:
  • • Using AI/algorithms as sole basis for claim denials
  • • Automated denials without human physician review
  • • AI determining medical necessity without doctor input
  • • Algorithm-based denials of specialist-recommended care
Required:
  • • Human physician must review AI-flagged denials
  • • Disclosure when AI used in decision-making
  • • Patient right to request human review
  • • Documented clinical rationale for all denials
  • • Penalties up to $500,000 per violation

How to Use This Law

Signs of AI-Based Denial:
  • Denial issued within minutes/hours of claim submission
  • Generic denial language without specific clinical justification
  • No physician name/credentials listed on denial letter
  • Denial contradicts specialist recommendation without explanation
  • Pattern of identical denials for different patients/conditions
Action Steps:
  1. Explicitly request human physician review (cite SB 1120)
  2. Ask insurer to disclose if AI was used in denial decision
  3. Demand peer-to-peer review with specialist in your condition
  4. Request specific clinical justification with medical literature
  5. File complaint with CA Dept of Managed Health Care if AI suspected
  6. Document timeline - fast denials suggest automation

Why This Matters Nationally

The Problem
Major insurers use AI to auto-deny millions of claims. UnitedHealth's algorithms reportedly denied 90% of rehabilitation care, many overturned on appeal. AI doesn't review medical records - just flags claims based on cost and historical patterns.
California's Impact
As largest insurance market, California's ban forces national insurers to change practices. Expected to reduce automated denials by 40-60%. Other states (NY, WA, IL) considering similar legislation for 2025-2026.
Patient Power
Even outside California, you can demand human review and question AI involvement. Document suspected AI denials and report to state regulators. Building national awareness of this issue.

State-by-State Appeal Rights

Your appeal process and rights vary by state - know your specific protections

California
89% Success Rate

Independent Medical Review (IMR) - binding decision

New York
85% Success Rate

External Appeal Process - binding decision

Texas
76% Success Rate

Independent Review Organization (IRO) - binding

Florida
71% Success Rate

External Review available

Illinois
79% Success Rate

Independent External Review - binding

Pennsylvania
73% Success Rate

External Grievance Review - binding

Not Your State? Here's What to Do

Find Your State Resources:

  • State Insurance Department: Search "[your state] insurance department health appeal"
  • Healthcare.gov: Federal external review process for ACA marketplace plans
  • State health advocate: Many states have patient advocate offices

Common Deadlines Nationwide:

  • Internal appeal: 180 days to file (from denial date)
  • External review: 4 months to file (from internal denial)
  • Urgent appeals: Can file immediately, decision in 72 hours

External Review: Your Most Powerful Tool

Independent medical review with 75-90% patient success rate

Who Reviews Your Case

  • Independent physicians with no insurer financial ties
  • Specialists in your condition (peer review requirement)
  • State-certified reviewers following medical evidence standards
  • No financial incentive to deny claims

What They Consider

  • Your complete medical records and treatment history
  • Treating physician recommendations and clinical justification
  • Current medical literature and evidence-based guidelines
  • Medical necessity based on your specific condition

Why It Works

  • Binding decision - insurer must comply if you win
  • No cost or minimal fee (usually free)
  • Medical focus - not limited by plan technicalities
  • High success rate - 75-90% overturn initial denials

How to Request External Review

Step-by-Step Process:

  1. Complete internal appeal first (except urgent cases)
  2. Request external review within 4 months of internal denial
  3. Contact your state insurance department or use insurer's ERO form
  4. Submit supporting documents: denial letter, medical records, doctor letters
  5. Independent reviewer assigned within 7-10 days
  6. Decision issued in 45-60 days (4 days if urgent)
  7. If approved, insurer must provide coverage immediately

Key Tips:

  • Don't wait: File as soon as internal appeal denied
  • Submit everything: More documentation increases success
  • Get doctor involved: Updated letter from treating physician helps
  • Use urgent process: If medically necessary treatment delayed
  • Keep copies: Document entire external review process
Success Rate by Issue Type:
• Medical necessity denials: 85-90%
• Prior authorization: 80-85%
• Experimental treatment: 70-75%
• Emergency care: 90-95%
• Out-of-network: 65-70%
• Step therapy: 75-80%

Bad Faith Insurance Claims

When insurers act in bad faith, you may have additional legal remedies

What Constitutes Bad Faith

Unreasonable Denial:
  • • Denying clearly covered treatment
  • • Ignoring specialist recommendations
  • • Using non-physician reviewers for complex cases
  • • Denying without reviewing medical records
Improper Investigation:
  • • Failing to request necessary medical information
  • • Not conducting proper review before denial
  • • Relying on outdated or incorrect information
  • • Ignoring submitted evidence
Unreasonable Delays:
  • • Prolonged review without justification
  • • Repeatedly requesting same documentation
  • • Missing response deadlines systematically
  • • Delaying urgent care decisions
Dishonest Practices:
  • • Misrepresenting plan coverage
  • • Providing false information about appeal rights
  • • Pressuring to accept inadequate settlements
  • • Destroying or altering documentation

Available Remedies

Non-ERISA Plans (Individual, Marketplace):
  • Compensatory damages: Denied benefits plus consequential damages (lost wages, additional medical costs)
  • Punitive damages: Can be 2-10x actual damages for egregious bad faith
  • Emotional distress damages: For anxiety, suffering caused by denial
  • Attorney fees: Insurer may pay your legal costs
  • Jury trial: Right to have case heard by jury
ERISA Plans (Employer-Sponsored):
  • Limited to denied benefits: Can only recover coverage value, no extra damages
  • No punitive damages: Federal ERISA law preempts state bad faith claims
  • No jury trial: Judge decides case
  • Attorney fees possible: In some cases if you win
  • Focus on appeal process: External review is primary remedy

When to Consider Legal Action

Strong Cases:
  • External review found in your favor but insurer won't comply
  • Pattern of unreasonable denials for same condition
  • Insurer ignored clear specialist recommendations
  • Significant delays causing medical harm
  • Non-ERISA plan (individual/marketplace)
Consider Attorney If:
  • Denied treatment worth $50,000+
  • Life-threatening condition delayed
  • All appeals exhausted unsuccessfully
  • Evidence of insurer misconduct
  • Complex ERISA issues involved
Alternative Actions:
  • File complaint with state insurance department
  • Report to Dept of Labor (ERISA plans)
  • Contact state attorney general consumer protection
  • Media/public pressure (social media, news)
  • Patient advocacy organizations

Critical Time Limits - Don't Miss These Deadlines

Missing a deadline can forfeit your rights - mark these on your calendar

180
Days

Internal Appeal Filing

From date of denial
Standard deadline nationwide. Some states allow longer.
30
Days

Insurer Response Time

For internal appeals
Insurer must decide within 30 days (72 hours if urgent)
4
Months

External Review Filing

From internal appeal denial
120 days to request independent review
45-60
Days

External Review Decision

Independent reviewer timeline
4 days if urgent medical situation

Urgent/Expedited Review Timelines

When Urgent Review Applies:
  • Standard timeline would seriously jeopardize life or health
  • Serious impairment to bodily functions
  • Dysfunction of any bodily organ or part
  • Severe pain requiring immediate treatment
  • Active cancer treatment or time-sensitive procedure
Expedited Timelines:
Internal Urgent Appeal:
72 hours
Maximum response time
External Urgent Review:
4 days
Business days for decision
Immediate Contact:
24 hours
Call insurer, don't wait for mail
Loading jurisdiction data...

Frequently Asked Questions

Expert answers to common health insurance denial questions

What's the difference between internal appeal and external review?

What is 'medical necessity' and who really decides?

What are my emergency care protections - can insurers deny ER visits?

What is California's 2025 AI denial ban and how does it help me?

What are ERISA limitations and why can't I sue for damages?

How do I get urgent/expedited review for time-sensitive treatment?

Can I get reimbursed if I already paid out-of-pocket for denied treatment?