Insurance companies deny 1 in 5 healthcare claims, but 80% of appeals succeed. Learn how to challenge improper denials, navigate prior authorization, understand EMTALA protections, and recover compensation for denied care.
Healthcare access denial occurs when an insurance company refuses to authorize or pay for medical care that you or your doctor believes is necessary. These denials take many forms: refusing to cover a prescribed medication, rejecting a request for surgery or specialist consultation, denying emergency room treatment, or declining payment for care you've already received.
The stakes are high. When insurers deny access to care, patients face impossible choices: pay thousands of dollars out of pocket, go without needed treatment, or delay care while fighting the denial. According to 2024 data, 60% of patients whose care was denied experienced delays, and half of those patients reported their medical condition worsened while waiting for approval.
There are two main categories of denials. Pre-service denials (also called coverage denials or prior authorization denials) happen before you receive care—your insurer won't approve the treatment your doctor recommended. Post-service denials (claim denials) happen after you've received care—your insurer refuses to pay the medical bill, leaving you responsible for potentially enormous costs.
Both types can be fought. Federal law and most state laws give you the right to appeal insurance denials, and the success rate is remarkably high—over 80% of appeals result in overturned denials. The problem? Fewer than 1% of patients actually appeal. Insurance companies count on your confusion, exhaustion, and ignorance of your rights. Don't let them win by default.
Your doctor recommends a surgery, specialist visit, medical test, or expensive medication, but your insurer requires pre-approval (prior authorization) and denies the request. Reasons given often include "not medically necessary," "experimental treatment," or "alternative treatments should be tried first." Prior auth denials accounted for 9% of all denials in ACA marketplace plans but have an 80%+ overturn rate on appeal, suggesting many are improper from the start.
The insurer claims the treatment, test, or procedure isn't "medically necessary" according to their internal guidelines—even though your doctor disagrees. This is the insurance company second-guessing your physician's clinical judgment. Medical necessity denials represented only 6% of denials in 2023 data, but they're among the most frustrating because they directly contradict your doctor's expertise. These denials often involve cutting-edge treatments, newer medications, or preventive care.
A hospital refuses to treat you in the emergency room, delays your care while checking insurance, or transfers you to another facility before stabilizing your condition. These denials violate the federal Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act (EMTALA), which requires hospitals to screen and stabilize all emergency patients regardless of ability to pay. EMTALA violations carry penalties up to $133,420 per incident for hospitals with 100+ beds, and patients can sue for compensatory damages including pain, suffering, and wrongful death.
Your claim is automatically denied by artificial intelligence software without a human reviewer examining your case. Class action lawsuits filed in 2023-2024 allege that UnitedHealth and Humana use AI tools (nH Predict) with a 90% error rate to systematically deny rehabilitation care, post-acute care, and other expensive treatments. These denials often involve boilerplate language and ignore individual patient circumstances. Courts have allowed these lawsuits to proceed, and several states are considering bans on AI-driven denials.
The claim is denied due to paperwork errors, missing information, incorrect billing codes, or failure to obtain required referrals. Administrative reasons accounted for 18% of denials—the second most common category. These denials have nothing to do with whether you need the care; they're bureaucratic obstacles. The good news: administrative denials are usually the easiest to overturn by simply correcting the paperwork and resubmitting. The bad news: they cause delays that can harm your health.
Your insurer denies or underpays a claim because the provider is out-of-network, even in situations where you had no choice (emergency care, no in-network specialists available, or you didn't know the provider was out-of-network). Out-of-network claims are denied at much higher rates—37% compared to 19% for in-network care. Several states and the federal No Surprises Act offer protections against surprise out-of-network bills, making these denials challengeable.
The insurer claims your policy doesn't cover the service at all, or you've reached a coverage limit (such as a maximum number of physical therapy visits or mental health sessions per year). These denials represented 16% of all denials. However, insurers sometimes incorrectly classify services as "excluded" when they should be covered, especially for preventive care, mental health parity, or maternity services. Federal laws like the Affordable Care Act and Mental Health Parity Act mandate coverage for many services insurers try to exclude.
Insurance companies are for-profit businesses, and every claim they pay reduces their profits. While not all denials are improper, there's an undeniable financial incentive to deny as many claims as possible and hope patients won't appeal. Here's why your claim might be denied:
The brutal math: if insurers deny 20% of claims and fewer than 1% of patients appeal, they avoid paying 19% of claims they legally owe. With billions in claims annually, this represents enormous savings. The December 2024 killing of UnitedHealthcare's CEO ignited public outrage over this practice, highlighting widespread frustration with denials motivated by profit rather than medical evidence.
Class action lawsuits allege UnitedHealth and Humana use AI algorithms (nH Predict) that deny claims without human review and have a 90% error rate. These systems prioritize cost-cutting over patient care, systematically denying rehabilitation services, post-acute care, and expensive treatments. The AI doesn't understand nuanced medical situations—it just identifies patterns associated with high costs and auto-denies them.
Insurers create internal medical policies that are more restrictive than accepted clinical standards. For example, they might require you to fail three cheaper medications before approving the one your doctor recommends, even if medical literature supports using the better drug first. These guidelines prioritize cost over outcomes and second-guess physicians who know your case.
The prior authorization process is deliberately complex and burdensome. Insurers require mountains of paperwork, multiple phone calls, and long waits—hoping doctors will give up or patients will pay out of pocket. The administrative reasons (missing info, wrong codes, lack of referral) that cause 18% of denials are often the insurer's fault, not yours.
Insurance companies know that sick, stressed patients often lack the energy to fight denials. The appeal process requires persistence, documentation, and knowledge of your rights. By making it difficult, insurers ensure most people give up. This is why fewer than 1% of denials are appealed despite an 80% success rate—the system works by wearing you down.
To be fair, not all denials are improper. Some claims genuinely lack documentation, involve non-covered services, or request experimental treatments without evidence. However, when 80-90% of denials are overturned on appeal, it's clear that the vast majority of initial denials shouldn't have happened in the first place. The system is rigged to deny first and ask questions later.
Answer a few questions to estimate potential compensation for denied care
Don't let insurance companies profit from improper denials. 80% of appeals succeed. Calculate your claim value and start your appeal today.
Pet died at the vet clinic? Insurance denied your claim? Thousands in bills? German law protects pet owners. Free Ombudsman services, malpractice claims, fee disputes. Complete guide to your rights.
EEOC recovered $700M for 21,000 workers in FY2024. 97% litigation success rate. Free filing, no lawyer needed, 180-300 day deadline. Complete guide to filing discrimination charges and getting compensation.
$328M New York. $175M Massachusetts. $19.4M New Jersey. California case worth billions. How Uber and Lyft stole wages through misclassification. Claim deadlines, eligibility, and how to file.
Workday lawsuit certified as nationwide class action. iTutorGroup $365K settlement. HireVue discriminates against deaf applicants. 83% of companies use AI to screen resumes. Your rights when algorithms discriminate.
Workday AI rejected 1.1 billion applications. Class action now covers millions. EEOC rolled back guidance but laws still apply. Complete guide to fight AI hiring bias.
$140B in medical debt affects 100M Americans. CFPB rule struck down July 2025. No Surprises Act still protects. Complete guide to dispute bills, protect credit, fight collectors.