Home/Consumer Rights/Subscription Trap

E-Subscription Trap: Free Trial Scams, Difficult Cancellation & Your Refund Rights

Understand your rights under ROSCA, California ARL, and FTC enforcement. Get your money back from subscription traps, dark patterns, and unwanted auto-renewals.

$2.5B
Amazon ROSCA Settlement (Sept 2025 - Largest Ever)
$51,744
FTC Civil Penalty Per ROSCA Violation (2024 Rate)
60 Days
Chargeback Deadline (Fair Credit Billing Act - File Now!)
76%
Subscription Sites Use Dark Patterns (FTC 2024 Study)

Calculate Your Subscription Refund

Estimate your refund potential for unwanted subscription charges

Subscription Refund Calculator

Answer these questions to estimate your refund

Our AI will analyze your description and guide you through the next steps

What is a Subscription Trap?

A subscription trap is a deceptive business practice where companies make it easy to sign up for subscriptions but extremely difficult to cancel, or hide material terms like auto-renewal, price increases, or early termination fees.

In 2024-2025, subscription traps have reached epidemic levels, with the FTC studying 642 subscription sites and finding that 76% use "dark patterns" designed to trick or trap consumers.

Recent major enforcement actions show that companies are finally facing consequences: Amazon paid $2.5 billion (September 2025) for making Prime cancellation unreasonably difficult, Adobe faces an ongoing lawsuit for hiding early termination fees, and numerous other companies have settled for millions.

2024-2025 Critical Updates

  • FTC Click-to-Cancel Rule vacated by courts (July 2025), BUT enforcement continues through ROSCA
  • California AB2863 (effective July 2025): Stricter "express affirmative consent" requirement
  • Major 2025 enforcement: Uber (Apr), Paddle.com $5M (June), Care.com $8M (Summer), LA Fitness (Aug)

Your Legal Rights

  • Clear disclosure of ALL terms before billing (ROSCA § 8403)
  • Express informed consent required before charges (no pre-checked boxes)
  • Simple cancellation mechanism (as easy as signup)
  • 60-day chargeback right (Fair Credit Billing Act)
  • FTC complaint rights (can trigger enforcement)

When Can You Get a Refund?

You have strong legal grounds for a refund if the company violated ROSCA, state laws, or consumer protection regulations

1. No Clear Disclosure

Company failed to clearly disclose price, renewal terms, or cancellation policy
Terms were buried in fine print or separate pages you didn't see

2. Difficult Cancellation

Company required phone calls during limited hours (when you signed up online)
Multiple confusing pages, retention offers, or hidden cancel buttons

3. No Consent or Free Trial Trap

Charged without your knowledge or express consent
Free trial converted to paid without clear notice or reminder

4. Charges After Cancellation

You cancelled but company continued charging (strongest case type)
Not covered: Simply forgetting to cancel (unless terms were unclear)

Critical 60-Day Chargeback Deadline

The Fair Credit Billing Act gives you 60 days from the statement date (not the charge date) to dispute credit card charges. This is a STRICT deadline - file immediately if eligible.

For charges older than 60 days, you can still pursue direct refund demands, FTC complaints, state AG complaints, or small claims court (2-4 year statute of limitations).

How to Get Your Money Back: Recovery Methods

Multiple pathways to recover unwanted subscription charges, ranked by speed and success rate

Chargeback (Fastest)

30-60 Days

File with credit card issuer within 60 days. Success rate: 70-85% with good evidence. Fastest path to refund.

Best for recent charges

FTC/State AG Complaint

6-12 Months

Can trigger enforcement actions resulting in company-wide refunds. Amazon $2.5B included full refunds to all affected consumers.

Best for systematic violations

Small Claims Court

2-4 Months

For amounts $500-$10,000. No attorney needed. Success rate: 70-80% with proper documentation of ROSCA violations.

Best for $500+ amounts

Step-by-Step: Get Your Refund

Follow this comprehensive action plan to recover unwanted subscription charges

1
File Credit Card Chargeback (CRITICAL: 60-Day Deadline)

If you paid by credit or debit card, file a chargeback immediately. This is often the fastest way to get your money back.

  • Contact card issuer (number on back of card)
  • Explain: 'unauthorized recurring charges' or 'services not as described'
  • Provide evidence: cancellation attempts, lack of disclosure, screenshots
  • STRICT 60-day window from statement date - file within 1-3 days of discovery

2
Demand Refund from Company (Use Legal Language)

Send formal written demand citing ROSCA violations and stating consequences if not resolved.

  • Email + certified mail to company's registered agent
  • State specific ROSCA violations (§ 8403)
  • Demand refund within 10 business days
  • Cite consequences: FTC complaint, state AG, chargeback, legal action

3
File FTC Complaint at ReportFraud.ftc.gov

Your complaint contributes to enforcement patterns. Amazon's $2.5B settlement began with consumer complaints.

  • File at ReportFraud.ftc.gov (10-15 minutes)
  • Cite specific ROSCA violations
  • Upload evidence (screenshots, emails)
  • Can trigger company-wide investigations and restitution

4
File State Attorney General Complaint

Especially powerful in California (CART taskforce), New York, Illinois.

  • Search '[your state] Attorney General consumer complaint'
  • Cite state auto-renewal laws (California ARL for CA residents)
  • Explain financial harm and ROSCA violations
  • California CART: over $5M in 2024 settlements

Critical Deadlines & Time Limits

Act quickly - some deadlines are strict and missing them can cost you hundreds or thousands in refunds

Credit Card Chargeback

60 days from statement date

STRICT DEADLINE under Fair Credit Billing Act. File immediately - this is usually the fastest refund method (30-60 day turnaround).

FTC/State AG Complaint

File anytime

No statute of limitations for regulatory complaints. File even for older charges - can trigger company-wide enforcement and restitution.

Small Claims Court (US)

Varies by state (CA: 4 years)

Statute of limitations for breach of contract claims. California: 4 years for written contracts, 2 years for oral. Check your state law.

EU 14-Day Right

14 days from purchase

EU Consumer Rights Directive: 14-day cooling-off period for distance contracts (online/phone purchases). No reason needed for cancellation.

California ARL Private Suit

3-4 years (statute of limitations)

California Automatic Renewal Law allows consumers to sue companies directly. Private right of action with attorney fee recovery.

Platform Disputes (Amazon/eBay)

90 days (Amazon), 180 days (PayPal)

Amazon A-to-Z: 90 days from order. eBay Money Back: Contact seller within 30 days. PayPal Buyer Protection: 180 days from purchase.

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about subscription traps, refund rights, and recovery methods

What is a subscription trap and how does it work?

Can I get a refund if I simply forgot to cancel my subscription?

Loading jurisdiction data...

Get Your Money Back from Subscription Traps

File chargebacks, FTC complaints, and demand refunds using your legal rights

Free FTC complaints60-day chargeback right$51,744 FTC penalties per violation