Nursing home abuse, informed consent violations, patient dumping, Stark Law kickbacks, genetic discrimination. Learn your patient rights, file complaints with state agencies, and recover compensation for healthcare violations not covered elsewhere.
This page covers important healthcare issues that don't fit neatly into our other categories (medical billing, prescription coverage, data breaches, access denials, or medical records). These are diverse problems affecting patients across all healthcare settings—from nursing homes to genetic testing labs to hospital discharge units.
What unites these issues is that they involve violations of fundamental patient rights, systemic healthcare fraud, or institutional failures that harm vulnerable patients. Examples include nursing home neglect where staff fail to provide basic care, informed consent violations where patients undergo procedures without proper explanation of risks, patient dumping where hospitals transfer patients for financial reasons, kickback schemes where doctors order unnecessary tests to profit from financial arrangements, and genetic discrimination where employers or insurers use your DNA against you.
These issues often involve regulatory violations enforced by multiple agencies: state health departments oversee nursing homes and hospitals, the Department of Justice prosecutes healthcare fraud under the False Claims Act, EEOC handles genetic discrimination complaints, and CMS enforces EMTALA patient dumping rules. Recent enforcement shows the government is taking these violations seriously—$52 million recovered from physicians in recent years, $21.3 million from Texas healthcare providers in 2024 alone, and individual penalties reaching into the millions for filming patients without consent.
If your healthcare problem doesn't match our other specific categories but you believe your patient rights were violated, you're in the right place. We'll help you understand what happened, which agency to contact, how to document your complaint, and what compensation you may be entitled to recover.
Physical abuse (hitting, restraining), emotional abuse (yelling, threats), sexual abuse, financial exploitation, and neglect (inadequate food, hygiene, medical care, supervision leading to bedsores, malnutrition, falls, infections). Nursing home complaints can be filed with state ombudsmen (confidential patient advocates), state health departments, and Adult Protective Services. Lawsuits can recover compensation for injuries, pain, suffering, and punitive damages. Document everything with photos, medical records showing decline, and witness statements from other residents or families.
Hospitals transferring or discharging patients who are medically unstable, or refusing emergency treatment based on inability to pay. Patient dumping violates EMTALA. Hospitals must screen and stabilize all emergency patients regardless of insurance or finances. Violations result in penalties up to $133,420 per incident plus civil lawsuits. If you were transferred while unstable, discharged too early and had to return to the ER, or refused emergency treatment, file an EMTALA complaint with CMS and consult an attorney immediately.
Undergoing surgery, procedures, or treatments without being properly informed of risks, benefits, and alternatives. Doctors must explain what they're doing, why, material risks involved, other treatment options, and consequences of declining treatment—and get your voluntary agreement. Lack of informed consent is medical malpractice. Settlements range from $100,000 to over $1 million depending on harm caused. Exceptions exist for emergencies when you're unable to consent. You must prove you wouldn't have agreed if properly informed of the risks that materialized.
Being filmed, photographed, or having your medical images used without proper written consent. Your image is protected health information under HIPAA. Recent penalties: Massachusetts General $515,000 (ABC film crew), NY Presbyterian $2.2 million (TV show), Cadia Healthcare $182,000 (social media photos). If you were filmed without consent or your photos were used in marketing, social media, TV shows, or teaching materials, file a HIPAA complaint with OCR and sue for invasion of privacy and emotional distress. Document where and how your images were used.
Receiving unnecessary medical care because your doctor had financial incentives to order tests, procedures, or hospitalizations. Stark Law prohibits physician self-referrals; Anti-Kickback Statute prohibits kickbacks for referrals. 2024 settlements: Texas providers $21.3M, Oroville Hospital $10.25M (bonuses based on admission volume), Methodist Le Bonheur $7.25M. If you suspect unnecessary care due to financial arrangements, you can file a whistleblower lawsuit under the False Claims Act (potentially earning 15-30% of government recovery) or sue for medical malpractice if the unnecessary treatment harmed you.
Being discriminated against in employment or health insurance based on your genetic information (genetic test results, family medical history). The Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act (GINA) prohibits this discrimination. GINA does NOT cover life insurance, disability insurance, long-term care insurance, small employers (under 15 employees), or military. File complaints with EEOC (employment discrimination, 180-300 day deadline) or HHS Office for Civil Rights (health insurance discrimination). You can recover compensatory and punitive damages. Note: direct-to-consumer genetic testing companies (23andMe, Ancestry) are NOT covered by HIPAA and can sell your data—read privacy policies carefully.
Home health aides, nurses, or therapists providing inadequate care in your home: medication errors, failure to follow care plans, inadequate wound care causing infections, falls due to lack of supervision, failure to report changes in condition, theft, or abuse. Report to the home health agency, file complaints with your state health department (agencies are regulated), report to Medicare (1-800-MEDICARE if Medicare-certified), and consider Adult Protective Services if abuse occurred. Home health agencies are liable for their employees' negligence. You can recover compensation for resulting injuries and harm.
Your doctor unilaterally terminating the doctor-patient relationship without proper notice (typically 30 days), time to find a new provider, or ensuring continuity of care. Examples: doctor stops treating you mid-treatment without warning, refuses to renew necessary prescriptions without notice, doesn't respond to urgent calls from established patient. Patient abandonment is medical malpractice. File complaints with your state medical board (doctors can face license suspension) and sue if abandonment caused harm (worsened condition, complications). Document all attempts to contact the provider and get alternative care immediately.
Being discharged from the hospital without appropriate discharge planning, resulting in preventable readmission or complications. Medicare regulations require hospitals to evaluate post-discharge needs, identify follow-up care requirements, involve you in planning, and arrange necessary services. Premature discharge can be patient dumping (if medically unstable), medical malpractice (if it causes harm), or Medicare fraud. Medicare beneficiaries can request a "fast appeal" to stay in the hospital during review (call 1-800-MEDICARE immediately). File complaints with state health departments and document any harm from premature discharge.
Broader patterns of healthcare fraud where patients are victims: unnecessary surgeries or procedures performed for profit, upcoding (billing for more expensive services than provided), billing for services never rendered, performing medically unnecessary tests due to financial arrangements. These violations are prosecuted under the False Claims Act. Patients can file whistleblower lawsuits (qui tam actions) and potentially earn 15-30% of government recovery. DOJ has recovered over $52 million from healthcare providers in recent years. If you know of systemic fraud, consult a whistleblower attorney—many work on contingency and can help expose fraud while protecting your identity.
Right to understand your treatment, risks, benefits, and alternatives before agreeing to any procedure.
Right to emergency medical screening and stabilization regardless of ability to pay (EMTALA).
Right to privacy under HIPAA. No one can access your records without authorization, film you without consent.
Right to refuse any treatment (with rare exceptions for infectious disease quarantine or court-ordered treatment).
Right to respectful treatment free from discrimination, abuse, neglect, or retaliation.
Right to appropriate pain assessment and management. Providers can't withhold pain relief punitively.
Right to file complaints with facilities, state agencies, ombudsmen without fear of retaliation.
Right to continuous care. Providers must give proper notice before terminating relationship (typically 30 days).
Federal Nursing Home Reform Law (1987) guarantees these rights. Contact Eldercare Locator: 1-800-677-1116 to find your state ombudsman.
You (the patient) - can file complaints about your own care to state health departments, ombudsmen, medical boards, and regulatory agencies.
Family members or legal representatives - can file on behalf of patients who are incapacitated, minors, or deceased. You may need Power of Attorney or guardianship documentation for some agencies.
Healthcare workers (whistleblowers) - nurses, doctors, aides, or administrative staff who witness healthcare fraud, patient abuse, or regulatory violations can file complaints under whistleblower protections. Federal False Claims Act protects whistleblowers from retaliation and rewards them with 15-30% of government recovery.
Concerned third parties - neighbors, friends, or community members can report suspected nursing home abuse or neglect to Adult Protective Services or ombudsmen. Many states allow anonymous reports.
Estate representatives - executors or personal representatives of deceased patients' estates can pursue wrongful death claims for medical malpractice, nursing home negligence, or patient dumping that caused death.
Important: You don't need a lawyer to file complaints with government agencies—they investigate for free. However, consult an attorney for medical malpractice lawsuits, wrongful death claims, or False Claims Act whistleblower cases as these are complex and have strict deadlines.
Economic damages must be documented with receipts, bills, employment records, expert testimony for future costs.
Non-economic damages compensate for intangible harms. Some states cap these damages in medical malpractice cases.
Awarded in cases of egregious misconduct, willful negligence, or fraud to punish defendants and deter future violations.
Punitive damages can significantly exceed economic and non-economic damages but are difficult to obtain—you need clear evidence of intentional or reckless conduct.
Under the False Claims Act, whistleblowers who report healthcare fraud can earn 15-30% of government recovery.
Example: 2024 Texas whistleblower case resulted in $21.3M recovery. Whistleblower likely earned $3.2M-$6.4M (15-30%). Protected from retaliation.
September 2024: Five Texas healthcare providers settled False Claims Act allegations of Stark Law and Anti-Kickback Statute violations. Providers allegedly paid bonuses to physicians based on volume of referrals and admissions, resulting in unnecessary hospitalizations and procedures.
Why it matters: Demonstrates DOJ focus on kickback arrangements that harm patients through overtreatment. Whistleblowers likely earned $3.2M-$6.4M (15-30%).
August 2024: Oroville Hospital (California) settled allegations that it paid compensation to emergency department physicians based on volume of patients admitted, violating Anti-Kickback Statute and leading to unnecessary admissions.
Why it matters: Hospitals can't incentivize doctors to admit more patients. If you were hospitalized unnecessarily, this shows pathway to recovery.
December 2023: Tennessee hospital system settled allegations of paying neurosurgeons above fair market value in exchange for referrals, violating Stark Law and Anti-Kickback Statute.
Why it matters: If your doctor referred you for expensive neurosurgery you didn't need, investigate their financial relationship with the facility.
2019 Settlement: NY Presbyterian Hospital paid $2.2M for allowing patients to be filmed for a TV show ("NY Med") without proper HIPAA-compliant authorization. Patients were filmed in emergency rooms, operating rooms, and dying.
Why it matters: Your image is protected health information. Filming requires explicit written consent explaining how footage will be used.
Massachusetts General Hospital fined $515,000 for allowing ABC film crew to record patients without proper consent, including a man dying in the emergency room.
Why it matters: Even prestigious hospitals face severe HIPAA penalties for filming violations. If you were filmed, file OCR complaint immediately.
State Health Department
For: Nursing homes, hospitals, home health agencies. Google "[your state] health department complaint" to find online forms. Most states have 24/7 hotlines.
Long-Term Care Ombudsman
For: Nursing home issues. Confidential patient advocates. Find yours: Eldercare Locator 1-800-677-1116. Ombudsmen investigate and help resolve complaints.
CMS (Medicare)
For: Patient dumping (EMTALA violations), Medicare-certified facilities. File online at cms.gov or call 1-800-MEDICARE.
HHS Office for Civil Rights
For: HIPAA violations (filming without consent, unauthorized photo use). File at hhs.gov/ocr within 180 days. Free complaint process.
State Medical Board
For: Individual doctor misconduct (patient abandonment, informed consent violations). Can result in license suspension. Google "[your state] medical board complaint."
EEOC / HHS
For: Genetic discrimination (GINA violations). File with EEOC (employment) within 180-300 days or HHS OCR (health insurance).
DOJ / State Attorney General
For: Healthcare fraud whistleblowing (Stark Law, Anti-Kickback, unnecessary procedures). Consult whistleblower attorney first—you may earn 15-30% of recovery.
Be specific and factual. Include:
After filing:
Timeline: 30-90 days for initial investigation, 6-12 months for complex cases
Immediate threats (life safety) investigated within 24-48 hours. Routine complaints 30-90 days. Nursing home investigations typically include on-site inspections.
Timeline: 1-4 weeks for resolution
Long-Term Care Ombudsmen work quickly to resolve nursing home complaints. Simple issues (family visit restrictions, missing items) resolve in days. Complex issues (systematic neglect) may take weeks.
Timeline: 6-12 months investigation
OCR has 180 days to investigate but can extend. Large penalties (like $2.2M NY Presbyterian) can take 1-2 years to finalize.
Timeline: 1-4 years from filing to resolution
Discovery: 6-18 months. Depositions and expert reports. Settlement negotiations or trial preparation: 6-12 months. Trial if no settlement: 1-2 weeks. Appeals can add 1-2 years. Most cases settle before trial.
Timeline: 2-7 years from filing to recovery
DOJ investigation: 1-3 years (case sealed during investigation). If DOJ intervenes: 1-3 years to settlement. If DOJ declines, you can proceed yourself: 2-5 years. Texas $21.3M case likely took 3-5 years total.
Timeline: 3-9 months for CMS investigation
CMS investigates within 3-6 months. Penalties assessed quickly. Separate civil lawsuit for damages: 1-3 years.
Important: Time limits to file complaints
Don't wait—the sooner you file, the stronger your case and better your chances of recovery.
Waiting weeks or months to take photos, write notes, or get records. Evidence disappears—injuries heal, memories fade, staff turnover, facilities delete data.
Fix: Document everything as soon as it happens. Take photos with timestamps. Write detailed notes same day.
Nursing homes often require arbitration clauses in admission contracts, limiting your right to sue in court. Arbitration favors facilities.
Fix: Strike arbitration clauses before signing. Many states make them unenforceable if you object. Consult attorney before signing nursing home admissions.
Filing complaints or lawsuits after statutes of limitations expire. HIPAA: 180 days. Malpractice: 2-3 years. EEOC: 180-300 days. EMTALA: 2 years.
Fix: File immediately. Don't wait to "see what happens" or hope facility fixes problem. Deadlines are strict.
Relying on memory or your own notes without official medical records. You need objective proof from facility's own documentation.
Fix: Request complete medical records immediately (you have right under HIPAA). Records often show facility knew about problems and failed to act.
Facilities offer quick lowball settlements hoping you'll accept before talking to lawyers or understanding full extent of damages.
Fix: Never sign releases or accept settlements without consulting attorney. Most offer free consultations. Initial offers are usually 10-30% of case value.
Filing with only one agency. Each agency (state health dept, ombudsman, CMS, OCR) has different powers and remedies.
Fix: File with ALL applicable agencies. Not mutually exclusive. State investigates facility operations, CMS addresses Medicare violations, OCR handles HIPAA, lawsuits get compensation.
Confronting staff or administrators alone. They'll deny, deflect, or claim you're mistaken. No record of conversation.
Fix: Bring witness (family member, patient advocate). Follow up in writing via certified mail summarizing conversation. Create paper trail.
Believing facility will honestly investigate and hold staff accountable. Internal investigations almost always conclude "no wrongdoing."
Fix: Report to external agencies immediately. Facility has conflict of interest. State health departments and ombudsmen provide independent investigation.
88-year-old Dorothy developed stage 4 bedsores due to nursing home's failure to reposition her regularly. Family documented progression with weekly photos. Medical records showed facility ignored care plan. Autopsy revealed sepsis from infected bedsores caused death.
What worked: Weekly photo documentation, ombudsman complaints triggering state inspection, medical expert testimony that bedsores were preventable with proper care. Wrongful death lawsuit settled 18 months after filing.
Robert signed general consent form but wasn't told surgery had 15% chance of permanent nerve damage. Surgeon performed procedure, nerve damage occurred, Robert lost function in right hand. Testified he would have refused surgery if properly informed of this specific risk.
What worked: Consent form was generic (didn't list nerve damage), medical literature showing 15% risk known to surgeons, expert testimony that reasonable person would decline with that risk level. Jury verdict after 9-day trial.
Hospital nurse witnessed doctors admitting patients unnecessarily to meet volume quotas for bonuses. Collected internal emails showing bonus structure. Filed False Claims Act whistleblower lawsuit. DOJ investigated 2 years, hospital settled for $21M. Whistleblower earned 15%.
What worked: Detailed documentation of admission patterns, internal communications about quotas, expert analysis showing admissions were medically unnecessary. Whistleblower protected from retaliation, identity sealed during investigation.
Maria brought to ER with severe chest pain. No insurance. Hospital performed EKG, gave aspirin, discharged her 90 minutes later telling her to "follow up with cardiologist." She collapsed in parking lot, permanent heart damage. Medical records showed she was still unstable.
What worked: CMS investigated, confirmed EMTALA violation, fined hospital $133,420. Civil lawsuit resulted in $425K settlement for permanent injuries. Security footage showed she collapsed immediately after discharge.
James disclosed family history of Huntington's disease during company wellness screening. Fired 3 months later for "performance reasons" despite excellent reviews. Discovered emails referencing his "genetic situation" and concerns about future healthcare costs.
What worked: Filed EEOC complaint within 180 days showing timeline correlation. Discovery revealed internal emails violating GINA. Employer settled rather than face trial. EEOC supports genetic discrimination claims aggressively.
Answer a few questions to estimate potential compensation
Know your patient rights. Report violations to state agencies. Recover compensation for healthcare harm.
Refus de remboursement, dépassements d'honoraires, erreurs de facturation - les patients français ont des droits solides selon le Code de la santé publique et Code de la sécurité sociale. Stratégies éprouvées avec 86% de réussite, jurisprudence récente et procédures détaillées.
Justice workplace a réalisé victoire historique récemment avec EEOC sécurisant près de 700 millions dollars pour victimes discrimination emploi - augmentation 5% et plus haute récupération monétaire histoire récente.
Découvrez la crise cachée de la discrimination au logement avec 34 150 plaintes déposées en 2025. De la victoire de 2,275 millions de dollars contre la discrimination algorithmique aux stratégies concrètes de lutte : votre guide complet pour défendre vos droits au logement équitable.
Votre médecin dit que vous avez besoin d'un traitement urgent. Votre assurance dit que vous avez d'abord besoin d'une permission. Bienvenue en enfer de l'autorisation préalable—où 94% des médecins signalent des retards de traitement.