Uber, DoorDash, Instacart deactivated you without reason? Withheld your pay?
You're not alone. 59 million gig workers deserve fairness.
Free tools • No credit card • AI-powered analysis
Miguel drives for Uber, delivers for DoorDash, shops for Instacart. Seventy hours last week. Gross earnings: $847. Gas: $210. Car payment (required for platform): $115. Insurance (commercial, required): $87. Phone data: $25. Maintenance fund: $50. Depreciation on 2019 Camry: $120. Net: $240. That's $3.43 an hour. Uber's quarterly report: $1.2 billion profit. CEO compensation: $24.3 million. Miguel's status: Independent contractor. No benefits. No minimum wage. No rights.
Tuesday, 2 AM. The app pings. Delivery request: 14 miles for $4.75. Decline. Acceptance rate drops to 67%. At 65%, algorithm starts hiding good orders. Catch-22: Accept money-losing trips or lose access to profitable ones. Miguel accepts. Burns $6 in gas to make $4.75. The algorithm notes his desperation. Next offer: 16 miles for $4.25. The price discovery works one direction—down.
Reasons drivers got deactivated in 2024 (no appeal, no warning):
California AB5 tried to fix this. Prop 22 killed it with $200 million campaign. Written by Uber, funded by DoorDash, passed by confused voters.
Jennifer accepts Instacart batch. Three orders, 47 items, 8.2 miles. Shows $42 total with "$25 tip." Shops for 90 minutes. Perfect replacements. Friendly messages. Delivers with smile. Check earnings: $17. Customer removed tip after delivery. Instacart keeps their fee. Jennifer burns gas, time, dignity. Customer gets free labor. Happens daily. Instacart's solution: "We encourage customers to tip fairly." That's it. That's the protection.
DoorDash's version: Hide tips over $4. Driver sees "Total may be higher." Gambles on mystery amount. Delivers to mansion, hoping for big tip. Total was $4.50. The hidden 50 cents? Tony Xu (CEO) worth $1.3 billion thinks transparency hurts "marketplace dynamics." Translation: Desperate drivers work harder when they don't know what they'll earn.
You're an independent contractor when: Paying taxes, buying insurance, maintaining vehicle, taking liability.
You're controlled like an employee when: Must accept certain percentage, wear branded gear, can't set prices, penalized for breaks.
Benefits you get from either status: Zero.
Massachusetts lawsuit revealed: Uber and Lyft owe drivers $175 million in back pay. Settlement requires paying $32.50 minimum wage going forward. Other 49 states? Still $3.43 after expenses.
Marcus delivered for Amazon Flex. Dog attack, 47 stitches, permanent nerve damage. Workers comp claim? Denied—independent contractor. Amazon's insurance? Doesn't cover contractors. His insurance? Doesn't cover commercial activity. Hospital bill: $31,000. Amazon's response: Account deactivated for "failure to complete route." Disability payment: $0. SSDI application: Denied, made too much as "business owner" last year. The perfect trap.
Sarah, Lyft driver, sexually assaulted by passenger. Reported to Lyft. Their response: "We take safety seriously," then nothing. No investigation. Passenger still active. Sarah's PTSD makes driving impossible. Income: Zero. Lyft's safety report: "99.9% of rides occur without incident." The 0.1%? Those are people, not statistics. 3,824 sexual assaults reported to Uber in 2019-2020. Real number? Nobody knows. Most don't report. Why bother? You're not an employee.
What they tell you: "High demand = higher prices for drivers!"
What actually happens:
New Year's Eve 2024: Passengers paid $400+ for rides. Drivers made $90. Uber's cut: 77%. "Partnership."
The unionization attempts failed spectacularly. Why? Apps immediately flood market with new drivers when organizing starts. Seattle drivers tried. Uber/Lyft recruited 10,000 new drivers in three weeks. Rates crashed. Organizers couldn't afford to continue. Message received. California drivers organized. Prop 22 passed with gig company backing. Now need 7/8 legislature majority to change anything. Democracy, sponsored by DoorDash.
The data tells everything. Average gig worker tenure: 3 months. Why? They do the math. Realize they're losing money. Car breaks down. Can't afford repairs. Deactivated for arbitrary reason. The platforms don't care. Infinite supply of desperate people. 500,000 new drivers signed up in 2024. 400,000 quit. The churn is the feature. Experienced drivers know the true pay. New drivers still believe the ads. "$30/hour!" (before expenses, during surge, if lucky).
What you're legally entitled to in most states:
Biden's Department of Labor proposed employee classification rule. Business groups sued. Rule blocked. Status quo maintained.
Here's the truth: Gig economy isn't innovation. It's regression to pre-labor-law exploitation with an app. The platforms extracted $400 billion in value while classifying workers as "entrepreneurs." Miguel isn't an entrepreneur. He's a servant to an algorithm that cuts his pay while monitoring his every move. The solution exists: Employee classification, sectoral bargaining, portable benefits. But that would cut into that $1.2 billion quarterly profit. So Miguel drives another 14 miles for $4.75, burning his car's value for Uber's stock price. The algorithm notes his acceptance. Tomorrow's offer: 14 miles for $4.50. The race to the bottom has no floor. That's not a bug. That's the business model.
Most Common: Deactivation for low acceptance rate, customer complaints, alleged ToS violations
Success Rate: 42% of appeals succeed with proper documentation
Average Payout: $500-$5,000 in unpaid wages + reactivation
What We Do: Generate appeal letter, compile evidence, demand arbitration
Most Common: Withheld tips, completion rate penalties, false fraud accusations
Success Rate: 65% recover withheld pay within 30 days
Average Recovery: $800-$2,000
What We Do: Payment dispute letter, fraud defense, class action notification
Most Common: Cancellation rate deactivation, missing batch payments, unfair quality scores
Success Rate: 38% reactivated with appeal
Average Loss: $1,200/month during deactivation
What We Do: Reactivation appeal, payment recovery, score dispute
"DoorDash withheld $4,200 in tips over 6 months. Compens.ai generated my dispute letter, I sent it, and had my money within 18 days."
"Deactivated after false customer complaint. Used the appeal template, got reactivated in 11 days, plus back pay for time I couldn't work."
"Joined class action for algorithmic discrimination. 14 months later, got $12K settlement check. Worth the wait."
AB5 (2020): Created the "ABC test" - If platform controls how you work, you're an employee. Uber, Lyft, DoorDash drivers should be employees with minimum wage, overtime, benefits.
Prop 22 (2020): Gig companies spent $200 million to pass ballot measure exempting themselves from AB5. Wrote own rules: 120% minimum wage (only during active trips, not waiting), $0.30/mile for expenses, healthcare stipend if 25+ hours/week.
Reality Check: "120% minimum wage" only counts engaged time. Wait 20 minutes between rides? Unpaid. Drive to pickup? Unpaid. Actual hourly: $6-$8 after expenses in many markets.
Current Status (2025): Prop 22 ruled unconstitutional by Alameda County court (Aug 2021), appealed, CA Supreme Court reviewing. Meanwhile, drivers still "independent contractors."
The irony: AB5 required legislature supermajority to change. Prop 22 requires 7/8 legislature to amend. Gig companies gave themselves permanent law, harder to change than California Constitution.
Settlement (June 2024): AG Maura Healey sued Uber and Lyft for $175 million in back wages for misclassification.
Terms: $32.50/hour minimum for engaged time, sick leave, occupational accident insurance, right to appeal deactivation.
The Catch: "Engaged time" still doesn't include waiting for requests or driving to pickup. Drivers report real earnings: $18-$22/hour after expenses.
Why This Matters: First US state to get enforceable minimum wage for gig drivers. Other states watching closely.
Seattle Ordinance (Jan 2024): $19.97/hour minimum wage for engaged time plus $0.35/mile for expenses.
Platform Response: Uber/Lyft immediately increased rider fees 30%, blamed city council, threatened to leave market (didn't).
Driver Reality: Take-home improved $3-$5/hour. Still not employee status, still no benefits, still can't unionize.
TLC Rules (2023): $18.96/hour minimum for app-based drivers, adjusted annually for inflation. Includes paid sick leave, workers comp.
Unique Aspect: NYC Taxi & Limousine Commission has jurisdiction over ride-sharing. Most cities don't.
Loophole: DoorDash, Instacart not covered - only transportation, not delivery.
Federal Classification: IRS 20-factor test or "economic reality" test. Gig workers usually classified as independent contractors.
Your Rights: Must be paid what you're owed (tips, fees), can't be deactivated for protected class, can arbitrate or sue (if not waived).
What You DON'T Get: Minimum wage, overtime, unemployment insurance, workers comp, health insurance, right to organize.
Average gig worker in these states: $8.55/hour after expenses (MIT Living Wage Calculator, 2024)
Screenshot: Every trip, delivery, payment, rating, deactivation notice
Save: Customer messages, platform emails, app notifications
Track: Hours worked, miles driven, actual earnings vs projected
Evidence: Doorbell camera footage (false "not delivered" claims), dashcam (false complaints)
Platforms delete data after 90 days. Get it now.
Gross Earnings: What app shows you made
Minus Gas: Miles × your car's MPG × gas price
Minus Depreciation: IRS standard $0.67/mile (2024)
Minus Insurance: Commercial coverage premium
Divide by TOTAL Hours: Including waiting, pickup driving
Below minimum wage in your state? You may be misclassified.
Deactivation: Use platform's appeal process (usually email or app form)
Withheld Pay: Report via app, follow up with email, demand response within 7 days
Be Specific: "On January 15, 2025, order #12345, customer claimed non-delivery. Doorbell camera at 123 Main St shows me delivering at 6:47 PM. Reactivate my account."
42% of documented appeals succeed. Vague appeals fail.
State Labor Board: File wage claim for unpaid wages, tips
Attorney General: Consumer protection complaint (deceptive practices)
Federal: EEOC (discrimination), NLRB (retaliation for organizing)
Arbitration: Most gig contracts require it - demand it, platforms often settle
Labor board complaints are free and can force platforms to respond.
Ongoing Lawsuits: Algorithmic discrimination, tip theft, misclassification
How to Join: Search "platform name class action" + your state, submit claim form
Average Payout: $300-$15,000 depending on case and your work history
Example: 2024 DoorDash tip skimming settlement: $2,400 average for affected dashers
Class actions take 1-3 years but require minimal effort.
Hire If: Owed $10,000+, discrimination/retaliation claim, injury while working, criminal false accusation
Contingency Fee: Most gig worker lawyers work on percentage (25-40% of recovery)
Free Consultations: Get 3-5 lawyer opinions before choosing
For under $5,000 owed, DIY appeal + arbitration threat often works.
All three must be true for independent contractor status:
A. Free from Control
Platform doesn't control HOW you do the work.
❌ Fails: Uber sets rates, assigns trips, penalizes for declining, requires acceptance rate minimums
B. Outside Usual Business
Work is outside the platform's usual business.
❌ Fails: Driving IS Uber's business. Shopping IS Instacart's business.
C. Independently Established
You have your own independent business in that trade.
❌ Fails: Most drivers don't have independent ride-sharing business outside app
Result: Under AB5, most gig workers should be employees. Prop 22 exempted platforms from this test.
Weighs multiple factors - no single factor is determinative:
✓ Points to Employee:
✓ Points to Contractor:
Reality: Factors split. Courts in different states rule differently. Many gig workers misclassified but federal test less protective than ABC test.
Legally: In most states, yes (at-will contractor relationship). Practically: They still must follow their own ToS and can't discriminate based on protected class. If deactivated for false accusation, you have right to appeal and demand evidence. 42% of documented appeals succeed. Platform can't deactivate you for reporting safety issues, filing wage claims, or discussing pay with other workers (NLRB protected activity).
1) Screenshot the original offer and final payment. 2) Report to platform via app (usually "earnings issue"). 3) If platform won't restore tip, file complaint with your state labor board as "wage theft" - tips are YOUR wages, not customer's to take back after service provided. 4) California workers: File with CA Labor Commissioner (free, 2-3 month resolution). DoorDash/Instacart settlements in 2024 paid $800-$2,400 average for tip-related wage theft.
Working for multiple platforms doesn't automatically make you a contractor (that's a myth platforms spread). Classification depends on how EACH platform controls your work. If Uber controls your rates, penalizes declining trips, and requires acceptance minimums, you may be misclassified EVEN IF you also do DoorDash. Multi-apping is common (67% of gig workers), but it's not a legal defense for the platform.
ABC test (CA, MA, NJ): All 3 must be true to be contractor - A) Free from control B) Work outside company's business C) Independently established trade. MUCH stricter - most gig workers would be employees. IRS test (federal, most states): Weighs many factors (control, financial relationship, type of work). More subjective, easier for platforms to argue contractor status. California's AB5 used ABC test until Prop 22 exempted gig companies.
Depends on state: CA (Prop 22): 120% minimum wage for engaged time only. MA: $32.50/hour engaged time. Seattle: $19.97 + $0.35/mile. NYC: $18.96. Other 46 states: NO minimum wage (contractor status). "Engaged time" = only when actively on trip/delivery, NOT waiting for requests or driving to pickup. If misclassified as contractor, you may be owed back wages at full minimum wage for ALL hours worked. File claim with state labor board.
Most gig contracts include arbitration clauses (you waived right to sue/join class action when you signed up). HOWEVER: 1) Some states ban arbitration for wage claims (CA). 2) You can opt-out within 30 days of signing up (most don't know this). 3) Mass arbitration threats work - if 10,000 workers demand arbitration at $2,000/case, platforms often settle. 4) NLRB recently ruled some arbitration clauses violate labor law. Check your contract for opt-out language or contact lawyer about challenging arbitration clause.
Most gig workers are NOT covered by workers comp (contractor status). Options: 1) Platform insurance: Uber/Lyft/Instacart have limited occupational accident insurance (up to $1M medical, but complicated claims process). 2) Your car insurance: Usually doesn't cover commercial activity. 3) Health insurance: If you have it. 4) Lawsuit: Sue at-fault party (other driver, property owner, dog owner). 5) Misclassification claim: If you can prove you're an employee, you'd be covered by workers comp retroactively. Get lawyer immediately if seriously injured.
Varies widely: Small payouts: $50-$500 (nuisance settlements, quick resolution). Medium: $500-$5,000 (tip theft, misclassification in single state). Large: $5,000-$15,000+ (major violations, long work history). Examples: Instacart tip settlement (2024): $2,400 average. Uber/Lyft MA settlement: $175M for 60K drivers = $2,900 average. Class actions take 1-4 years. Most pay out, but amounts depend on your documented work history and violation severity. Join early, provide documentation, wait patiently.
NO - this is NLRB protected activity under Section 7 of the National Labor Relations Act. You have the right to discuss wages, working conditions, and organize collectively EVEN AS A CONTRACTOR. Platforms often try to ban this in ToS, but it's illegal. If deactivated for discussing pay, organizing drivers, or complaining about working conditions: 1) File NLRB charge (free, online). 2) Screenshot all conversations about organizing. 3) You may be entitled to reinstatement + back pay. Recent NLRB rulings: Uber can't prevent drivers from sharing earnings info.
Engaged time (what platforms count): Only time with passenger in car or food in hand. From accept to drop-off. Total time worked (what you actually work): All time app is on, waiting for requests, driving to pickup, ending trip. Example: 10-hour shift, 6.5 hours engaged, 3.5 hours waiting/driving to pickups. Platform minimum wage ($20/hr engaged) = $130 for 6.5 hours. Real hourly: $130 ÷ 10 hours = $13/hour. This distinction lets platforms claim high pay while drivers earn less than minimum wage. Employee misclassification claims argue for total time worked.
Emerging legal area. Not explicitly illegal in most states, but: 1) If algorithm discriminates based on race, gender, age, disability = illegal under Title VII, state civil rights laws. 2) If algorithm detects desperation and pays less = potentially unfair business practice. 3) EU AI Act (2025) may ban "harmful" algorithmic management. Malaysia passed first gig worker algorithmic discrimination law (Sept 2025). US lawsuits ongoing: Uber accused of paying less to drivers who accept more trips (captive audience). Document if you suspect pay discrimination - screenshot identical trips paid differently to different drivers.
Usually NO (contractor status = ineligible), but: 1) CA/MA/NJ/WA: May qualify if you can prove misclassification. 2) Pandemic exception: CARES Act temporarily covered gig workers (ended 2021). 3) Appeal if denied: File UI claim, get denied, appeal and argue misclassification. Bring evidence of platform control. 4) Success rate low but worth trying if you have strong misclassification case. Some states (NY, CA) have approved UI for deactivated drivers who appealed with documentation showing employee-like control. Benefit amount: 40-60% of previous earnings, max $450-$900/week depending on state.
You have whistleblower protections: 1) OSHA protections: Can't be retaliated against for reporting unsafe working conditions. 2) NLRB protections: Can't be deactivated for raising concerns with other workers. 3) State protections: Many states ban retaliation for good-faith reports to authorities. If deactivated after reporting: 1) Document timeline: When you reported, what you reported, when deactivated. 2) File OSHA whistleblower complaint within 30 days. 3) File state retaliation complaint. 4) Possible remedies: Reinstatement, back pay, punitive damages. Instacart case (2023): Driver reported COVID exposure, deactivated, won $12,000 settlement + reactivation.
Complex: 1) Right now: Yes, IRS treats you as contractor, you pay 15.3% self-employment tax (both employer + employee portions). 2) If you WIN misclassification claim: Platform owes back taxes for employer portion (7.65%) + possibly unemployment taxes. You may get refund. 3) Strategy: File taxes as contractor to avoid IRS issues, ALSO file IRS Form SS-8 to request employee classification determination. Takes 6+ months. If IRS rules you're employee, platform owes back taxes. 4) You can still deduct mileage ($0.67/mile 2024), phone, supplies. Most gig workers owe little after deductions.
Resources: 1) TopClassActions.com - search "gig worker" or your platform name. 2) ClassAction.org - gig economy section. 3) Your state Attorney General website - ongoing settlements. 4) Google: "[platform name] class action [your state]". Current major cases (2025): Uber algorithmic discrimination, DoorDash tip transparency, Lyft sexual assault, Instacart wrongful deactivation. To join: Find case, submit claim form with work dates and documentation, wait (typically 1-3 years). Most require proof: Screenshots of earnings, dates worked, platform communications. Set calendar reminder to check settlement administrator websites quarterly.
Gig worker rights vary by jurisdiction - California's AB5 classifies many platform workers as employees, while other states use federal tests. Our AI analyzes your work arrangement, applicable classification tests (ABC test, IRS factors), and determines if you've been misclassified and entitled to employee protections. Fight back with AI. Generate your appeal letter in 3 minutes. Free.
No signup required • Works for all platforms • 100% free tools